Understanding Notched Box Plots:
Statistical Significance Visualization
Notched box plots add confidence intervals around the median, allowing you to visually assess whether differences between groups are statistically significant. Learn how to read them and when to use them.
Notched box plots add confidence intervals around the median, allowing you to visually assess whether differences between groups are statistically significant. Learn how to read them and when to use them.
1. What Are Notched Box Plots?
A notched box plot is a standard box plot with an additional feature: a notch (or confidence interval) around the median. This notch visualizes the uncertainty in the median estimate, allowing you to assess whether differences between groups are statistically significant.
The notch appears as a narrowing of the box around the median line. If you're comparing multiple groups in a grouped box plot, the notches help you quickly identify which groups have significantly different medians.
๐ก Key Insight
Rule of thumb: If the notches of two groups don't overlap, their medians are likely statistically significantly different. If the notches overlap, the difference may not be statistically significant.
2. How Notches Work: The Math Behind It
The notch represents an approximate 95% confidence interval for the median. It's calculated using the interquartile range (IQR) and sample size:
Formula
Standard Error = 1.57 ร (IQR / โn)
where n is the sample size
The notch extends from:
- Lower bound: median - standard error
- Upper bound: median + standard error
The constant 1.57 is chosen to approximate a 95% confidence interval for the median under normal distribution assumptions.
๐ Example
If median = 80, IQR = 15, n = 20:
Standard Error = 1.57 ร (15 / โ20) = 1.57 ร 3.35 โ 5.26
Notch extends from 80 - 5.26 = 74.74 to 80 + 5.26 = 85.26
3. Interpreting Notches: Reading Statistical Significance
The key to interpreting notched box plots is understanding what the notch overlap (or lack thereof) means:
โ Notches Don't Overlap = Likely Significant
If the notches of two groups don't overlap, their medians are likely statistically significantly different at approximately the 95% confidence level.
Example: If Group A's notch extends from 75-85 and Group B's notch extends from 90-100, there's no overlap. This suggests Group B's median is significantly higher than Group A's.
โ ๏ธ Notches Overlap = Possibly Not Significant
If the notches of two groups overlap, the difference between their medians may not be statistically significant. However, this is a visual approximationโformal statistical testing is still recommended.
Example: If Group A's notch extends from 75-85 and Group B's notch extends from 80-90, they overlap (80-85 range). This suggests the difference may not be significant, but you should verify with a formal test.
๐ Multiple Groups Comparison
When comparing multiple groups in a grouped box plot, look for groups whose notches don't overlap with others. These are likely significantly different.
Example: In a comparison of 5 groups, if Groups A, B, and C have overlapping notches, but Group D's notch doesn't overlap with any, Group D is likely significantly different from the others.
4. When to Use Notched Box Plots
โ Perfect For:
- Comparing multiple groups visually
- Quick assessment of statistical significance
- Exploratory data analysis
- Presentations where visual clarity matters
- When sample sizes are moderate to large (n โฅ 10)
- When you want to avoid formal hypothesis testing initially
โ ๏ธ Consider Alternatives For:
- Very small sample sizes (n < 10)
- When you need exact p-values
- Formal hypothesis testing requirements
- When notches are too wide (low precision)
- When comparing only two groups (t-test may be clearer)
๐ก Best Practice
Use notched box plots as a visual screening tool to identify potentially significant differences. For formal conclusions, follow up with appropriate statistical tests (e.g., ANOVA, Kruskal-Wallis, or t-tests).
5. Practical Examples
Example 1: Classroom Test Scores
Scenario: Compare test scores across three classes to see if there are significant differences.
Data:
Class A: 85, 87, 88, 90, 92, 93, 95 Class B: 75, 78, 80, 82, 85, 87, 90 Class C: 70, 72, 74, 76, 78, 80, 82
Result with Notches: Class A's notch likely doesn't overlap with Class B or C, suggesting Class A performs significantly better. Class B and C may have overlapping notches, suggesting their difference may not be significant.
โ Try this example in PlotNerd (enable notches) โExample 2: A/B Testing Results
Scenario: Compare conversion rates across three website variants.
Data:
Control: 2.1, 2.2, 2.3, 2.4, 2.5, 2.6 Variant A: 3.0, 3.1, 3.2, 3.3, 3.4, 3.5 Variant B: 2.5, 2.6, 2.7, 2.8, 2.9, 3.0
Result with Notches: Variant A's notch likely doesn't overlap with Control, suggesting a significant improvement. Variant B may have overlapping notches with both, suggesting it's intermediate.
โ Try this example in PlotNerd (compare with notches) โ6. Limitations and Considerations
โ ๏ธ Sample Size Matters
Notches are most reliable with moderate to large sample sizes (n โฅ 10). For very small samples, notches can be very wide, making them less informative. For large samples, notches become narrow, making differences easier to detect.
โ ๏ธ Approximation, Not Exact Test
Notched box plots provide a visual approximation of statistical significance, not an exact hypothesis test. They're based on assumptions (e.g., normal distribution) that may not hold for your data. Always verify with formal statistical tests when making conclusions.
โ ๏ธ Distribution Assumptions
The notch calculation assumes approximately normal distributions. For highly skewed or non-normal data, notches may be less reliable. Consider using MAD outlier detection or transformation for skewed data.
7. FAQ
Q: What confidence level do notches represent?
A: Notches represent an approximate 95% confidence interval for the median. The constant 1.57 in the formula is chosen to approximate this confidence level under normal distribution assumptions.
Q: Can I use notched box plots with grouped comparisons?
A: Yes! Notched box plots work excellently with grouped box plots. In PlotNerd, you can enable notches for both single and grouped box plots. Simply toggle the "Show Notches" option in the visualization panel.
Q: What if notches are too wide or too narrow?
A: Wide notches (small sample sizes) indicate high uncertaintyโdifferences may be harder to detect. Narrow notches (large sample sizes) indicate high precisionโeven small differences may be significant. If notches extend beyond the box (Q1-Q3 range), they're automatically clipped to the box boundaries for visual clarity.
Q: Should I always use notched box plots?
A: Not necessarily. Use notched box plots when you want to visually assess statistical significance between groups. For simple descriptions or when comparing only two groups, standard box plots or formal tests (t-tests) may be clearer. Notched box plots are most valuable for exploratory analysis with multiple groups.
Q: Can notched box plots replace formal statistical tests?
A: No. Notched box plots are a visual screening tool, not a replacement for formal hypothesis testing. They help you identify potentially significant differences, but you should follow up with appropriate statistical tests (e.g., ANOVA, Kruskal-Wallis) for formal conclusions, especially in research or publication contexts.
8. Conclusion
Notched box plots are powerful tools for visually assessing statistical significance between groups. By displaying confidence intervals around medians, they help you quickly identify which groups are likely significantly different without performing formal hypothesis tests.
Key takeaways:
- Non-overlapping notches suggest statistically significant differences
- Overlapping notches suggest differences may not be significant
- Use notches as a visual screening tool, not a replacement for formal tests
- Works best with moderate to large sample sizes (n โฅ 10)
With PlotNerd, you can easily enable notches in your box plots, whether you're comparing single groups or multiple groups in a grouped visualization. Combine notches with robust outlier detection methods for comprehensive statistical analysis.
Ready to Visualize Statistical Significance?
Try PlotNerd's notched box plot feature to see confidence intervals in action.
Create Notched Box Plot Now